The Warm Tale of Irish Coffee: A Drink Born of Necessity and Ingenuity
When you sip an Irish Coffee today—a delightful blend of hot coffee, Irish whiskey, sugar, and a crown of thick cream—you might picture cozy pubs, roaring fires, or St. Patrick’s Day celebrations. But the story of this iconic drink begins with a much humbler scene: a stormy night, a group of weary travelers, and a quick-thinking chef in 1940s Ireland.
A Chilly Night in Foynes
The tale starts in Foynes, a small village in County Limerick, Ireland, which during the 1930s and 1940s served as a bustling hub for transatlantic seaplane flights. Before the rise of modern airports, Foynes was a key stopover point for passengers traveling between Europe and North America. The flying boats of that era, however, were at the mercy of the weather, and the Irish climate—notorious for its wind and rain—often left travelers stranded.
On one particularly blustery night in the early 1940s (most accounts pinpoint 1942 or 1943), a flight bound for Newfoundland was forced to turn back to Foynes due to treacherous conditions. The passengers, cold, tired, and likely a bit grumpy, disembarked into the terminal’s restaurant seeking warmth and comfort. Enter Joe Sheridan, the head chef at Foynes, a man whose ingenuity would soon warm both bodies and spirits.
A Stroke of Genius
Sheridan, tasked with reviving these soggy travelers, didn’t just serve them standard cups of tea or coffee. Perhaps inspired by the Irish tradition of adding a splash of whiskey to just about anything—or simply by a desire to go the extra mile—he concocted something special. He brewed strong, hot coffee, stirred in a measure of Irish whiskey, sweetened it with brown sugar, and topped it with a layer of thick cream. When the passengers asked what they were drinking, Sheridan reportedly quipped, “Irish Coffee!”—and thus, a legend was born.
The drink was an instant hit. The coffee provided a jolt of energy, the whiskey a comforting warmth, the sugar a touch of sweetness, and the cream a luxurious finish that balanced the boldness of the brew. Word of this delightful concoction spread among the regular flyers, and it became a signature offering at Foynes.
From Foynes to San Francisco
The Irish Coffee might have remained a local curiosity if not for a serendipitous chain of events that brought it across the Atlantic. In the late 1940s, Foynes’ role as an aviation hub declined with the rise of land-based airports like Shannon, but the drink’s reputation endured. In 1952, a travel writer named Stanton Delaplane tasted Irish Coffee at Shannon Airport (where Sheridan had relocated after Foynes closed). Captivated by its charm, Delaplane brought the recipe back to the United States, specifically to the Buena Vista Cafe in San Francisco.
At the Buena Vista, Delaplane worked with bartender Jack Koeppler to recreate Sheridan’s masterpiece. Perfecting it wasn’t easy—the cream kept sinking into the coffee instead of floating atop it, a key element of the drink’s appeal. After much trial and error (and reportedly a trip to Ireland to consult with Sheridan himself), they cracked the code: lightly whipped, cold cream was the secret. On November 10, 1952, the Buena Vista served its first Irish Coffee, and it quickly became a sensation. The cafe claims to have popularized the drink in America, and to this day, it serves thousands of Irish Coffees weekly, often using a theatrical assembly-line pour for delighted patrons.
A Legacy of Warmth
Joe Sheridan eventually moved to the U.S. himself, working briefly at the Buena Vista before retiring. He passed away in 1962, but his creation lives on as a symbol of Irish hospitality and creativity. In 1983, a plaque honoring Sheridan was erected at Shannon Airport, cementing his place in culinary history.
Today, Irish Coffee is enjoyed worldwide, especially around St. Patrick’s Day or during chilly months. Purists might argue over the exact recipe—Jameson or Bushmills whiskey? How much cream?—but the essence remains unchanged: a drink born of necessity, perfected by care, and shared with the world.
So next time you cradle an Irish Coffee, take a moment to toast Joe Sheridan, the chef who turned a stormy night into a warm legacy—one sip at a time
Keep Reading to find your Pot of Gold
1. Classic Irish Coffee (Joe Sheridan’s Original Style)
This recipe reflects the traditional preparation attributed to Joe Sheridan in 1940s Ireland, focusing on simplicity and warmth. It’s the foundation of most modern variations.
Ingredients:
- 1 cup (6-8 oz) hot brewed coffee (strong, dark roast preferred)
- 1 oz Irish whiskey (e.g., Jameson or Bushmills)
- 1-2 tsp brown sugar (preferably demerara for richer flavor)
- 1-2 oz heavy cream (lightly whipped or cold, unwhipped, depending on preference)
Instructions:
- Preheat the Glass: Fill a heatproof glass (typically a 6-8 oz stemmed glass) with hot water to warm it, then discard the water.
- Add Sugar and Whiskey: Pour the brown sugar and Irish whiskey into the glass.
- Pour Coffee: Add the hot coffee, stirring until the sugar fully dissolves.
- Top with Cream: Gently float the heavy cream over the top by pouring it over the back of a spoon. The cream should sit atop the coffee without mixing in.
- Serve: Do not stir after adding the cream—sip the coffee through the cream for the classic experience.
Notes:
- Sheridan reportedly used unwhipped cream in his original, but lightly whipping it to a pourable consistency became popular later for better flotation.
- The balance of whiskey warmth and creamy richness is key
2. Buena Vista Cafe Irish Coffee (American Classic)
This version, perfected by the Buena Vista Cafe in San Francisco since 1952, is arguably the most famous adaptation and has shaped how Irish Coffee is enjoyed globally.
Ingredients:
- 6 oz hot brewed coffee (medium-dark roast, often a Colombian blend)
- 1.5 oz Irish whiskey (Buena Vista uses Tullamore D.E.W.)
- 2 sugar cubes (or about 2 tsp granulated white sugar)
- Heavy cream (cold, lightly whipped to a thick but pourable consistency)
Instructions:
- Preheat the Glass: Fill a 6 oz glass mug (typically a clear, stemmed one) with hot water to warm it, then pour out the water.
- Add Sugar: Drop the two sugar cubes into the glass.
- Pour Coffee and Whiskey: Add the hot coffee and Irish whiskey, stirring until the sugar dissolves completely.
- Float the Cream: Spoon or pour the lightly whipped heavy cream over the back of a warm spoon to create a distinct layer on top of the coffee.
- Serve Immediately: Drink without stirring, letting the cream blend naturally as you sip.
Notes:
- The Buena Vista emphasizes pre-whipping the cream slightly (often aged cream for better texture) and uses a specific glass to showcase the layers.
- Their assembly-line method—pouring dozens at once—has made this recipe iconic, with a slightly higher whiskey ratio than some traditional takes.
Here's your Pot of Gold
Use the Code GOLD20 and receive 20% off Gold Drops by Smart OWLchemy!
